Shop our selection of Paint Your Own Cookie Stencils! Kids of all ages love painting these sweet treats! Use our PYO stencils to create the perfect cookie decorating activity for birthday parties, holidays, and special events. From dessert designs and party animals for celebration cookies to pumpkins and pies for Fall cookies, we have a stencil to fit your theme. Try our new Sleigh and Bow design for Winter Cookies! And find all of the PYO accessories that you need to bake, decorate and package your cookies including Cookie Cutters Edible Paint Palettes, Brushes and more!
For information on how to decorate PYO Cookies, read our Blog Post!
$4.99
Our Christmas Ornament Paint Your Own Cookie Stencil is made on a 5.5" x 5.5" template. This PYO design features a Christmas ball that is...
View full product details$4.99
Our Ugly Christmas Sweater Reindeer PYO Cookie Stencil is made on a 5.5" x 5.5" template. Decorated with a cute reindeer face, this Paint Your...
View full product details
$9.99
A 2-piece PYO Set, Our Santa's Coming to Town Cookie Stencils features Santa Claus in his sleigh and the two reindeer pulling him in the...
View full product details$4.99
Our Ugly Hanukkah Sweater PYO Cookie Stencil is made on a 5.5" x 5.5" template. This Paint Your Own design features an ugly sweater with...
View full product details$4.99
Our Christmas Cupcake PYO Cookie Stencil is made on a 5.5" x 5.5" template. This cupcake stencil features a bright Christmas Tree. This design measures about 2"...
View full product details$4.99
Our Ugly Christmas Sweater Ornament PYO Cookie Stencil is made on a 5.5" x 5.5" template. The sweater design measures 2.70" wide x 2.25" tall...
View full product details$4.99
Our Ugly Christmas Sweater Gingerbread PYO Cookie Stencil is made on a 5.5" x 5.5" template. The sweater design measures 2.70" wide x 2.25" tall...
View full product details
$4.99
Our Cookies for Santa PYO Cookie Stencil features a plate full of sugar cookies for Santa, and of course carrots for the reindeer! design measures...
View full product details$4.99
Make Cookie Valentines with our 'You Melt My Heart' PYO Cookie Stencil. Popsicle design measures about 2.6" x 2.6". Kids of all ages will love...
View full product details
$4.99
Make Cookie Valentines with our 'You Are Dino-Mite' PYO Cookie Stencil. Brontosaurus with hearts design measures 2.5" W x 2.6" H Kids of all ages...
View full product details$4.99
Make Cookie Valentines with our 'You Are Mer-mazing' PYO Cookie Stencil. Mermaid design measures 2.5" W x 2.7" H. Kids of all ages will love...
View full product details$4.99
Make Cookie Valentines with our 'My Heart Beeps For You' PYO Cookie Stencil. The design measures about 2.7" and features a heart-filled robot! Kids of...
View full product details$4.99
Make Cookie Valentines with our 'I Chews You' PYO Cookie Stencil. The design measures about 2" W x 2.4" H and features a gumball machine...
View full product details$4.99
Our Truck of Hearts PYO Cookie features a a dump truck full of hearts! Available in two sizes: Small measures 2.75" W x 1.75" H...
View full product details
$4.99
Our Gingerbread House Paint Your Own Cookie Stencil is made on a 5.5 inch x 5.5 inch template. The design measures about 3.10" H x...
View full product details$4.99
Decorate Christmas cookies with our Joy PYO Cookie Stencil! This design features the word joy with an ornament and measures 3.1 W x 2" H Kids...
View full product details$4.99
Our Holiday Haul PYO Cookie Stencil features Christmas presents piled up on car. Kids of all ages will love decorating these Christmas Cookies! design measures 2.8"...
View full product details$4.99
Our Floral Pumpkin PYO Cookie Stencil features pretty flowers and fall leaves. Stencil design available in two sizes: Small measures 2.6" W x 2.5" H...
View full product details
$4.99
Our Christmas Truck PYO Cookie Stencil is made on a 5.5" x 5.5" template. This design measures about 2 3/4" W x 2" H and...
View full product details
$4.99
Our Stacked Present PYO Cookie Stencil features two wrapped presents tied together with a big bow. This stencil is perfect for decorating Christmas sweets and...
View full product details$4.99
Our Heart Gumball Machine PYO Cookie Stencil is made on 5.5" x 5.5" template. This design features heart-shaped gumballs and measures about 1.65" W x...
View full product details$4.99
Our Blast of Hearts PYO Cookie Stencil features a rocket ship with heart details! Design measures 2 1/2" W x 2 3/4" H Kids of...
View full product details$4.99
Decorate beautiful winter treats with our Snowflake PYO Cookie Stencil. The design measures about 3.15" in diameter. Kids of all ages will love painting these snowflake cookies!...
View full product details$4.99
Our Big Love PYO Cookie Stencil spells out the word 'LOVE' in a cool block font with a heart for the letter 'O' and an...
View full product details
